i was chosen as art director for my games art pipeline project, perhaps slightly against my will– but i had somewhat of a vision of where the game should be headed so i said alright. probably worst mistake of my life but also i feel like no one would do anything if i hadnt stepped up so… maybe it was for the better.
reverie’s end is a game focused on the separation of the dream world and the split reality that the main character, reverie, finds herself in. we decided on a lineless art style and bright saturated colors for anything that isn’t the MC to attain that sort of dreamy look.
some of my group members struggled with the art style demands, and therefore the end results of the assets are a little less than ideal. that wouldnt be that much of an issue– i told myself i could probably just edit them myself to look better later on and that we could use their items as placeholders. i didnt end up going through with it, since i understand this is a project that is marked individually instead of as a group, even though the end product may not look up to standards. i thought originally maybe it was disrespectful to feel this way… but to be honest i didnt end up having to worry about it, since i didnt physically have the time to edit anything anyways.
how do you motivate someone to do something without incentive? i was thinking this while begging for any of my group members to share their work in the shared team chat. a lot of the work was not finished, but started on the night before the deadline. it caused a lot of trouble regarding quality control and harmonious art style. as an example, i am responsible for the tilemap of the game, and my other group member does the background scenery art. it took pulling teeth to get them to send me their work in progress, and when they finally did i had already completed my tile sheet– and it looked completely different from their vision. i imagine the reasonable thing here would be to wait until they send me the asset so that we could coordinate better, but i personally prefer to give myself room to breathe when doing work. i don’t quite understand how to motivate people to work when money isn’t a factor, and their degrees don’t seem to matter to them. it made me a little sad that they weren’t as passionate about the project as i’d like them to be, even though i myself have had down times where i couldn’t find it in me to work.
something else i struggled with was giving constructive feedback. not that i couldn’t give it, but rather in what way i should come across. i understand that in the industry, an art director’s role would be to manage their team’s work quality and give critique when needed. however, it feels a little different when i’m still technically my group members’ peer, and have to manage a friendlier interpersonal relationship with them. i have had an experience where i have given feedback to someone, they rework it, and it still ends up subpar to expectations. how would i approach this situation without coming across too unpleasant? i dont think i quite found the answer even as this project nears its end.
i was responsible for communication between the game design team and my own, as well. i conducted a shared discord server for both teams, but the game design team was not as familiar with the platform, and thus required help with navigation. i did my best with communicating our needs and sending over our assets when completed, and i hope it’s enough for them despite the late delivery dates on a lot of assets not my own.
it was pretty hard communicating with the game design team as they are not creatives inherently, and dont understand the work we put into asset creation and how it correlates to their coding. there was a little bit of friction due to this, but hopefully i managed to smooth it over with them. i dont know. i made sure to attend every tuesday meeting with them even with most of my team not present, though admittedly it is a little embarrassing when they ask about the status of an asset and i’d have to tell them i’ve had no contact back from the specific artist….
i think my shortcomings as an inexperienced manager was part of the reason we became so disorganized. ideally, i should have conducted weekly checks with everyone to ensure progress was happening gradually, and followed up with people who struggled with their tasks more. but i also feel like there’s only so much i can do when some people just straight up reject communication of any kind until the very end. either ways, the project is like this now, and i can just hope to use this as an experience to do better in the future.
Leave a Reply